Shadow Duel: Fighting With a Blade in the Dark

The Shadow Duel game variant takes the familiar Shrine board and shrinks your visible army down to the essentials: a Sensei, two Disciples in the back corners, and a Ninja that starts hidden next to your Shrine.

The core turn structure is the same. You play a movement card, you move a visible piece, and you are still trying to capture the opposing Sensei or reach their Shrine. The difference is that every turn now has a second layer sitting on top of that: your Ninja can also move with that same card, in secret.

This mode is all about playing normal Hidden Path while constantly asking yourself, “What if there is a Ninja here?”

What actually matters in Shadow Duel

There are three things you care about on almost every turn:

  1. Is my Sensei safe from both visible pieces and a possible Ninja jump

  2. What can my Ninja do right now if I let it move with this card

  3. What does this card tell me about where their Ninja might be

You still cannot ignore the basics. If you walk your Sensei into an obvious capture, the Ninja will not save you. Your two Disciples still define most of the visible structure, and small trades still matter.

The Ninja sits on top of that as a force multiplier. When it works well, it turns ordinary moves into double threats. When it goes wrong, you reveal it for nothing and lose tempo.

Using your Ninja without throwing it away

The temptation in early Shadow Duel games is to use the Ninja every turn because it feels cool. That is usually a mistake.

A good Ninja move does at least one of these:

  • It brings the Ninja closer to the enemy Sensei or Disciples in a way that is hard to cover.

  • It sets up a future guess capture by getting behind the lines.

  • It quietly corrects your shape while your visible pieces pretend to be doing something else.

A bad Ninja move is one you are only making because you feel like you should “do something” with it.

Early in the game, it often makes sense to keep your Ninja fairly close to home. Let your Disciples stake out the center and get a sense of which cards are going to define the midgame. You can push the Ninja forward later, when the board is clearer and your opponent has already committed to a plan.

Revealing your Ninja is a big deal. You only want to do it when:

  • You are taking something that really matters, like a Disciple that is guarding their Shrine lane.

  • You are setting up a follow up that your opponent cannot easily punish, even if they know exactly where the Ninja is for a turn.

  • You are trading Ninjas and you think the resulting board is good for you.

If you reveal the Ninja just to pick off some random piece and then immediately lose it, you spent your special resource for nothing.

Reading where their Ninja can be

You never get to know exactly where their Ninja is, but you can do better than guessing purely at random.

A few simple habits help a lot:

  • Mentally track the first few cards they play. Any time they play a card, ask yourself, “If they moved their Ninja after this, where could it reach now?” You do not have to be perfect, just roughly aware.

  • Notice when they skip chances to move the Ninja. If they have a card that would let a Ninja jump into an obvious strong square and they do not take it, that often tells you the Ninja is not in range of that jump.

  • Pay attention to where their Disciples seem strangely cautious. If they keep refusing to move through or onto a particular square, there might be a Ninja standing on it.

You will never map out every possible path. That is fine. The goal is to rule out truly impossible squares and highlight the ones that are more likely. Over time you build a sense of “Ninja hot zones” and “Ninja cold zones” without needing to do full calculation.

Protecting your Sensei

On the 5×5 Shrine board, your Sensei cannot afford to wander around without support. With Ninjas in play, this is even more true.

A few practical rules:

  • Try not to let your Sensei get completely separated from both Disciples. If you leave it alone in open space, your opponent only needs one decent card and a Ninja in the right neighborhood to end the game.

  • Do not walk your Sensei onto a square where a Ninja plus a visible card can reach it in one step. Any time you play a card, glance at the pattern and ask, “If their Ninja were close, would this be a disaster next turn?”

  • Respect empty squares that feel “too good.” A square that both threatens their Sensei and seems unguarded is often the kind of place where a Ninja is waiting to punish you.

You will not avoid every tactic. The goal is to cut out the obvious self mates where you walk directly into a Ninja plus card combo that should have been easy to see coming.

When to go for a guess capture

Guess captures are the flashy part of Shadow Duel, and they should be rare.

The question is not “Can I guess?” It is “What happens if I am wrong?”

Good times to guess:

  • You are convinced their Ninja must be on one of a small number of squares, and hitting it would swing the game.

  • Your own Ninja is currently not doing much anyway, and stepping into the open for a turn is not fatal.

  • You are behind, and you need a high impact play to get back into the game.

Bad times to guess:

  • Your Ninja is your main source of counterplay, and revealing it for no gain would leave you helpless.

  • You have not really been tracking where their Ninja could be, so you are just clicking a random square.

  • You are already winning on the visible board, and you do not need to take unnecessary risks.

One useful habit is to pause before any guess and say out loud (or in your head), “If this is wrong, am I okay with my Ninja being revealed here for a full turn?” If the answer feels like “absolutely not,” then it is usually better to wait.

Openings, midgames, and endgames

In the opening, your main jobs are simple: get at least one Disciple into the center, do not blunder your Sensei, and do not reveal your Ninja for no reason. A Ninja that never moves in the first couple of turns is not wasted. It is just waiting for the board to give it something worthwhile to do.

In the midgame, things become more about timing. This is where well timed Ninja reveals can pick off isolated Disciples, and where both players are trying to line up Sensei runs while pretending they are not. Your Ninja often becomes a shadow that follows the direction of the card cycle, waiting for the one card that turns a quiet position into a direct threat.

Endgames with Ninjas are weird and fun. When there are very few visible pieces left, almost every empty square near the Sensei or Shrine feels dangerous. It is often correct to leave certain squares alone entirely, not because you know a Ninja is there, but because losing if you are wrong is too expensive.

If it comes down to a position where you are sure their Ninja is close and you have one realistic guess, it can be worth committing. Even missing and revealing your Ninja can clarify the position in a way that lets you play the rest of the endgame more confidently.

Shadow Duel is still the same Hidden Path under the hood. You still move with cards. You still defend your Sensei and hunt theirs. The Ninja does not replace any of that, it just adds a second game on top of the first one where both of you are trying to read not only the board and the cards, but each other.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mastering the Master’s Path

Master’s Path is the core of Hidden Path Dojo: a Sensei, four Disciples, five movement cards, and just enough room to hang yourself if you don’t respect the system. Sensei and Shrine: don’t forget either Every position has two pressure points: Your Sensei Their Shrine You lose when your Sensei dies or when their Sensei reaches your Shrine. Most disasters come from forgetting one of those for exactly one turn. On every move, quickly check: “Is my Sensei safe if they use their best card?” “If their Sensei steps forward here, do I still have a clean way to stop a Shrine run later?” If a capture or flashy tactic fails those tests, it’s probably not worth it. The real timing of the cards The most important thing people get wrong: the move you play now becomes their tool later, not immediately. When you play a card: It leaves your hand and sits in the middle. Your opponent takes their turn with their current cards. Only then does your card enter their hand...
Read more

Quickplay Matchmaking, Friend Challenges, and Reconnects

The biggest recent step for Hidden Path Dojo is something simple that changes everything about how you play here. We now have a Quickplay matchmaker . You and another person can just be on the site at the same time, click Quickplay, and the server will pair you into a game. No manual room codes, no sharing URLs, no setup screens. Just queue and play. You also do not need to be logged in to use Quickplay. It takes you straight into the queue using the current Quickplay server settings. Current Quickplay defaults Right now, the Quickplay queue runs with a specific default ruleset. You can think of it as the “standard ladder” for the site. The current Quickplay defaults are: All cards are enabled The mode is always Master’s Path The Spirit’s Breath air elemental is enabled 25% of the time If the air elemental is present, there is a random number of wind cards between 0 and 5 These numbers and choices will probably evolve as more people play, but this gives us a cons...
Read more

Welcome to Hidden Path Dojo

Hidden Path Dojo really started with a single idea that was not mine at all. I fell in love with the rotating movement card system from Shimpei Sato’s game Onitama . The board is simple, the pieces are simple, but the way a small shared set of movement cards rotates through both players’ hands turns every game into a little tactical puzzle. You never have access to everything. You are always planning with what you have now, what you are about to hand over, and what you expect to see again later. That rotating movement card mechanic is what I think of as the Hidden Path system . Hidden Path Dojo exists to explore that system in as many ways as possible. New games, new variants, new modes - all built on that shared, rotating pool of movement cards. Looking for a place to play The next part is very practical. Two player abstract strategy games are not the easiest thing to get to the table. They are intense, they are not always friendly to mismatched skill levels, and a lot of peop...
Read more